Testimonials

As usual it was great working with you. In my opinion you are the BEST Broker on the Island and as an extra Bonus a real nice person.  ... Read more

Highly likely to recommend. Our experience with Penelope Moore for the sale of our home was completely positive. Her years of experience in the Shelter Island market provided clear and calm explanations to our questions during the process. Penny understands the many nuances of Shelter Island  ... Read more

Penelope was an invaluable resource to us when we sold our house on Shelter Island. Penelope facilitated the sale with a high level of professionalism, was actively involved at all stages of this transaction and was always available to provide good counsel. In our opinion, there is no one better  ... Read more

The process of selling our home through Penelope could not have been less painless. She knows the market inside out, was honest, straightforward and extremely professional. We would highly recommend using Penelope in any Shelter Island real estate transaction.  ... Read more

Penny is a really great agent -- we couldn't recommend her more highly. In selling our house, we found her to be a tireless worker, constantly thinking of the best way to present our property in new and creative ways. She also happens to be a lovely person, with a rare knack of putting everyone at  ... Read more

Penny was a great asset to us during the entire sales process. She has high local market knowledge, was very active/responsive in marketing our home, and followed through on completing our sale within 6 months. I highly recommend her services in the Shelter Island marketplace.  ... Read more

Penelope is a sharp, patient and excellent real estate broker. Not to mention she has an amazing knowledge of the inner workings of Shelter Island. From first time vacation home buyers, to experienced real estate tycoons, you would be well served to have her in your arsenal while house hunting  ... Read more

After I set up an appointment and told Penny what I wanted, she did her homework and showed me homes that matched my criteria--she didn't waste time showing me homes that didn't. Simply put, she listens. She also impressed me because she knew the history of each home's property, ownership,  ... Read more

We used several other brokers over a four years span in attempting to sell our home in a very difficult housing market. We then asked Penelope Moore to meet with us and discuss marketing strategy. Penelope immediately told us what we needed to do in order to maximize our potential to sell our home.  ... Read more

Penelope listened carefully to what it was we were looking for in a home and respected our budget. Using her extensive knowledge of the area she was able to narrow down our search to homes that truly fit our criteria. During negotiations with the seller we had many hurdles to overcome and she  ... Read more

I listed two Shelter Island houses with Penelope Moore. One has already sold. I couldn't be happier with Penelope's hands-on professional approach. She is realistic about the process, and filters possible purchasers. I'm sure we'll have success in selling the second home also. I wouldn't hesitate to  ... Read more

I came to Penelope based on her excellent reputation. She did not disappoint. The sale of my home involved a very difficult, controlling, buyer. There were no issues with my home, but the buyer pushed every button she possibly could for months. During all of this Penelope remained poised, followed  ... Read more

You know the market better than anyone on that island. You are the only one I trust out there to sell my home. As always, thanks for the excellent counsel and candidness.  ... Read more

I must say, Penelope, that you are one industry agent. How could anybody think of going with anyone else?  ... Read more

Thanks so much for all you help! It was a pleasure working with you, why can’t all real estate brokers have your attitude?  ... Read more

Thank you for working for us on the sale. It really was a pleasure to work with you. We really appreciate you and Kim keeping on eye on the house during the winter and dealing with the various issues that arose... Thank you so much. I will recommend you highly to anyone that is looking on island.  ... Read more

Thanks for everything. You have been very patient with us over the years and we have definitely come to trust your advice. You were a pleasure to deal with (which is saying something in your profession).  ... Read more

I wanted to thank you for all of your help during the sale of our house - you certainly went out of your way, much above the call of duty, to accommodate everyone involved in the sale. I really appreciate your having made the transaction run so smoothly. People of your caliber and nature and  ... Read more

We had been looking for over 2 years, in part because there was not a lot on the market and in part because we had very specific requirements. Penelope was the first broker I ever met who actually listened to what those requirements were and acted on them. After several intensive days searching she  ... Read more