Shelter Island Market Report – The First Half of 2018

In 2018, the highest sale year to date has been $1,950,000 while in 2017, the highest sale for the same time frame was $4,504,500. 

 

In contract and waiting to close are 8 transactions totaling $11,595,000 based on last asking price. Several transactions, when sold and closed, will provide a solid foundation to the market with strong numbers. 

 

The 4th of July holiday week was active in our real estate market, with showings in all price ranges. Customers included those just entering the market and others who have been on the hunt for an extended period of time and who have just re-invigorated their home search.

 

As expected, 4th of July having landed on a Wednesday, offered both sellers and buyers ten days of overlapping long weekends with good weather. After a long winter and a spring filled with inclement weather, everyone welcomed the first real glimpse of summer and the return of an active real estate market. 

 

The inventory continues to be light in every price category from starter homes to estate homes, but also provide excellent opportunities for buyers. During the first half of 2018, the lowest price home sold was $600k with 5 sales from $600k to $700k; 3 homes from $849k to $885k; 5 homes from $940k to $999k; 5 homes from $1,050m to $1.3m. And 3 waterfront homes: $1,715m, and 2 at $1.95m were at the top. The statistics for the first half of 2018  point to more transactions being completed at lower price points than for the same time frame in 2017, however summer and autumn in the last three years have been periods where higher priced sales have transpired. 

 

Vacant land has been an option to buyers who had been looking for a home and decided to build their own. 

• 14 Peconic Avenue, a 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch built in 1959 on .5 acres with pool on creekfront, listed 8/23/17 for $2.1m, sold for $1.95m on 6/27/18;
• 68 Peconic Avenue, a 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath ranch built in 1954 on .74 acres with pool on soundfront, listed 6/12/17 for $3.125m, last listed at $2.75m, sold for $1.95m on 6/10/18;
• 16 Westmoreland Drive, a 5 bedroom, 3 bath cape built in 1965 on 1.07 acres with pool on bayfront, listed 9/20/13 for $2.75m, last listed at $1.95m, sold for $1.715m on 5/6/18;
• 4 Simpson Avenue, a 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath renovated farmhouse built in 1935 on .53 acres listed 9/30/17 for $1.395m, sold for $1.3m on 1/10/18;
• 4 Winthrop Road, a 6 bedroom, 3.5 bath farmhouse built in 1950 on .37 acres with pool, listed 2/15/18 for $1.395m, sold for $1.2m on 4/12/18;
• 1 Sandpiper Road, a 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath traditional built in 1967 on 1.1 acres with pool, listed 5/10/17 for $1.4m, sold for $1.275m on 2/15/18;
• 157 North Ferry Road, a 5 bedroom, 3 bath victorian built in 1900 on 1.74 acres comprised of two lots, one creekfront, listed 5/13/17 for $1.25m, sold for $995k on 5/8/18. The .83 acre creekfront has been re-listed by the buyer for $835k.
• 2 Margarets Drive, a 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath contemporary built in 1987 on .98 acres with deeded water rights and pool, listed 4/2/18 and sold 6/22/18 for $1,055m;
• 20 Terry Drive, a 4 bedroom, 2 bath contemporary built in 1984 on .52 acres with deeded beach rights and pool, listed 7/14/16 for $875k, sold for $885k on 6/25/18;
• 143 North Ferry Road, a 4 bedroom, 1.5 bath farmhouse built in 1893 on .47 acres, listed 7/4/16 for $795k, sold for $600k on 3/1/18;
• 12 North Menantic Road, vacant land, 11.7 acres, listed 8/12/17 for $2.135m, sold for $1.575m on 6/1/18
• 6 Lord’s Lane, vacant land, 2.2 acres creekfront with dock, listed 4/15/16 for $1.58m, sold for $1.1m, on 6/27/18;
• 4 Oxford Avenue, vacant land in the Heights, .37 acres listed 7/9/17 for $485k, sold for $400k on 1/8/18;
• 47 Lake Drive, vacant land, 1.2 acres listed 11/10/16 for $469k, sold for $445k on 1/31/18;
• 17 North Midway Road, vacant land, 1.01 acres listed 5/10/17 for $395k, sold for $345k on 6/18/18.